PART 3 — The Name on His Screen
I looked back at Ryan.
He had no idea I had seen the message.
She still doesn’t know about us.
Six words.
Six words that should have made me scream.
Instead, they made me strangely calm.
Because the name beneath them belonged to someone I had known for almost eight years.
Someone who had sat at my kitchen table.
Someone who had brought birthday presents for Sophie and Ben.
Someone who had hugged me when my mother went into the hospital.
Someone who had listened while I complained about my marriage and told me Ryan was “lucky to have me.”
My friend.
Lauren Hayes.
For one terrible second, I wondered whether I had imagined it.
Maybe there was another Lauren.
Maybe I had read the name wrong.
Maybe my mind was desperately trying to create another explanation because the obvious one hurt too much.
Then Ryan tilted his phone away from me.
That tiny movement destroyed every excuse I was trying to make for him.
He had something to hide.
And suddenly, I knew exactly who he was hiding.
“You okay?” he asked.
I forced myself to look at his face.
“Fine.”
“You look strange.”
“I’m tired.”
His eyes stayed on me.
Ryan had known me for twelve years.
He could tell when I was upset.
But there was one thing he had never understood about me.
When I was truly hurt, I didn’t get louder.
I got quieter.
And right then, I became very quiet.
Ryan slipped his phone into his pocket.
“So… about that guy.”
I almost laughed.
My husband had apparently been secretly involved with one of my closest friends, yet he was standing in our bedroom worried about a man I had spoken to for less than an hour.
“What about him?”
“Did you call him?”
“No.”
“Are you planning to?”
I studied him.
“Why does it matter?”
“It doesn’t.”
“Then why are you asking?”
Ryan exhaled.
“Emily, we’re still married.”
There are moments in life when someone says something so absurd that anger briefly disappears because your brain needs time to appreciate the hypocrisy.
This was one of those moments.
“Yes,” I said slowly. “We are.”
“So I think there should still be some respect.”
I nearly smiled.
“Respect.”
“Yes.”
“That’s important to you?”
“Obviously.”
I nodded.
“Good to know.”
Ryan frowned.
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
“Nothing.”
I picked up one of Ben’s shirts and folded it.
Ryan remained standing there.
I could feel him watching me.
He knew something had changed.
He just didn’t know what.
Finally, he walked downstairs.
I waited until I heard the television turn on.
Then I closed the bedroom door.
My hands started shaking.
Not while he was there.
Not while I was looking at him.
Only after he left.
I sat on the edge of the bed.
Lauren.
Memories started coming back.
Not dramatic ones.
That would have been easier.
Small ones.
Lauren standing beside Ryan at Ben’s seventh birthday while they carried a tray of drinks outside.
Lauren laughing too hard at something Ryan said during our Fourth of July barbecue.
Lauren volunteering to help him clean the kitchen after Thanksgiving dinner.
Ryan mentioning that Lauren had recommended a restaurant downtown.
Lauren asking whether Ryan was traveling for work the following month.
Things I had never questioned.
Why would I?
She was my friend.
Then I remembered something else.
Three months earlier, Lauren had come over while Ryan was supposedly working late.
We sat at the kitchen island drinking tea.
I had been exhausted.
The kids had been fighting all evening.
Ryan had been working late more often.
And I told her something I now wished I had never said.
“I feel invisible sometimes.”
Lauren had reached across the counter and squeezed my hand.
“Ryan loves you.”
“I know.”
“Then talk to him.”
“I’ve tried.”
She had looked sympathetic.
So sympathetic.
“Maybe he’s going through something too.”
At the time, I thought she was defending him because she was trying to help.
Now I wondered whether she had already known exactly what he was going through.
Because she was part of it.
My phone was still in my hand.
I opened my messages.
Lauren and I had texted two days earlier.
She had sent me a picture of shoes she was thinking about buying.
I had told her the black pair looked better.
Normal.
Completely normal.
I scrolled backward.
Birthday messages.
Memes.
Pictures of our kids.
Dinner plans.
Then something caught my attention.
A message from five weeks earlier.
Lauren:
Are you guys doing anything Saturday?
Me:
Probably not. Ryan has some work thing. Why?
Lauren:
Just wondering if you wanted to grab dinner.
That Saturday, Lauren canceled our dinner plans at four in the afternoon.
Migraine.
Ryan left at six thirty for his “work thing.”
He returned shortly after midnight.
I stared at the messages.
My stomach twisted.
Maybe coincidence.
Maybe not.
I needed facts.
Not assumptions.
Not anger.
Facts.
So I did something I had never imagined doing in my own marriage.
I opened my laptop and started making a timeline.
Dates Ryan had worked late.
Dates Lauren had canceled plans.
Business trips.
Weekends.
Parties.
Anything I could remember.
At first, there was nothing undeniable.
Then I opened our shared credit card account.
Ryan usually used his personal card for work expenses.
But occasionally he used our joint card accidentally.
I went back three months.
Gas.
Groceries.
Streaming services.
A hardware store.
Then I saw it.
Saturday.
The same Saturday Lauren had canceled dinner.
The Bellweather Hotel — $286.42.
I stopped breathing.
The Bellweather was downtown.
Less than ten minutes from the restaurant Lauren and I had planned to visit.
Ryan had told me his work event was at a conference center on the other side of town.
I clicked the transaction.
There wasn’t much information.
Just the amount.
The date.
And the merchant.
I took a screenshot.
Then another memory surfaced.
Ryan had come home that night smelling different.
Not perfume.
Soap.
I had teased him.
“Did your work event include a shower?”
He had laughed.
“Someone spilled beer on me. I cleaned up in the bathroom.”
I believed him.
Why wouldn’t I?
Trust makes ordinary explanations powerful.
Betrayal makes them look ridiculous afterward.
I searched the next month.
Another charge.
A restaurant.
Two people could easily spend that amount.
Then parking near Lauren’s office on a Sunday when Ryan told me he had gone to the gym.
I saved everything.
At 5:42 p.m., Sophie knocked on the bedroom door.
“Mom?”
I closed the laptop.
“Come in.”
She walked inside holding a worksheet.
“Dad said you know fractions better.”
Of course he did.
I almost laughed.
Even in the middle of destroying our marriage, Ryan was outsourcing homework to me.
“Come here.”
Sophie climbed onto the bed.
For the next twenty minutes, we worked through fractions.
And something important happened.
My anger settled.
Because Sophie didn’t know.
Ben didn’t know.
Whatever Ryan and Lauren had done, my children were not going to become collateral damage.
I wasn’t going to scream across the dinner table.
I wasn’t going to drag them into adult betrayal.
I was going to be careful.
That night, after the kids were asleep, Ryan came into the bedroom.
“I’m going out tomorrow.”
I looked up from my book.
“Okay.”
His eyebrows lifted.
“That’s it?”
“What else should I say?”
“I don’t know.”
“Where are you going?”
He hesitated.
“Drinks.”
“With?”
“Someone.”
There it was.
The open marriage.
Officially beginning.
Except Ryan didn’t know I understood that his version had started months earlier.
“Have fun.”
He stared at me.
“You’re really okay with this?”
I looked at him.
“Isn’t that what you wanted?”
“Yeah.”
“Then why do you look disappointed?”
“I’m not disappointed.”
He was.
Or maybe nervous.
He had expected jealousy.
Maybe tears.
Maybe a last-minute demand that we close the marriage again.
Instead, I turned another page.
Ryan stood there for a few seconds.
Then he went to shower.
His phone was on the dresser.
I looked at it.
I could have grabbed it.
I didn’t.
I didn’t need to.
Because I already knew where he was going.
Or at least I had a strong suspicion.
The next morning, I called Rachel.
I told her everything.
For once, Rachel didn’t make a joke.
“Lauren?”
“Yes.”
“Our Lauren?”
“Apparently.”
“I’m going to kill her.”
“No.”
“Fine. I’m going to strongly dislike her from a legally acceptable distance.”
Despite everything, I laughed.
Then Rachel became serious.
“What are you going to do?”
“Find out how far it went.”
“Emily, you already have a hotel charge.”
“I know.”
“So why torture yourself?”
“Because if I confront Ryan now, he’ll tell me whatever protects him.”
Rachel was quiet.
“And Lauren?”
“Same.”
“So what do you need?”
I hesitated.
“Ryan’s going out tonight.”
“Oh.”
“I think he’s meeting her.”
Another pause.
“You want me to follow him?”
“No.”
“Good, because I’m terrible at surveillance.”
“I want to go out.”
Rachel laughed once.
“Wait.”
“What?”
“You’re serious.”
“Completely.”
“With me?”
“No.”
Silence.
Then Rachel said one word.
“Daniel.”
I looked at the business card on my dresser.
“I haven’t decided.”
“You kept his card.”
“For work.”
“Of course.”
“Rachel.”
“Emily, I’m not telling you to date him.”
“Good.”
“I’m telling you to call him about the freelance work.”
I looked at the card again.
That felt different.
Safer.
More importantly, it felt like something that belonged to me rather than something I was doing in response to Ryan.
So after we hung up, I sent Daniel an email.
Hi Daniel,
It was nice meeting you the other night. I’ve been thinking about what you said regarding freelance design work. If the offer was genuine, I’d be interested in hearing more.
Emily
I stared at it for almost a minute before pressing send.
Twenty-seven minutes later, he replied.
The offer was absolutely genuine.
Would you like to grab coffee tomorrow afternoon and talk about a project?
I smiled.
Not because a man wanted to see me.
Because somebody had remembered something I was good at.
Something beyond being Ryan’s wife.
Something beyond being Mom.
I replied yes.
That evening, Ryan got ready carefully.
Too carefully.
He showered.
Shaved.
Changed shirts twice.
I watched from the doorway.
“Big night?”
He glanced at me.
“Just drinks.”
“Right.”
“What?”
“Nothing.”
He chose the blue shirt again.
Apparently betrayal had a uniform.
At seven fifteen, he kissed the children goodbye.
Then he approached me.
There was an awkward moment when he seemed unsure whether he should kiss me.
I solved the problem by stepping aside.
“Have fun.”
His expression tightened.
“You’re not going anywhere?”
“No.”
Again, relief.
That relief irritated me more than I expected.
He wanted freedom.
He simply didn’t want me to use mine.
Ryan left.
I waited.
Twenty minutes.
Thirty.
Then my phone buzzed.
Lauren.
Hey! Haven’t heard from you today. Everything okay?
I stared at the message.
The audacity almost impressed me.
I typed:
Everything’s great. You?
Her reply arrived quickly.
Good! Quiet night at home. Netflix and wine lol.
I looked at the screen.
Quiet night at home.
Interesting.
I didn’t answer.
Instead, I opened the shared location app our family used.
Months earlier, Ryan had insisted we all install it after Sophie started walking home from school with friends.
Ryan’s location sharing was still on.
I hadn’t expected that.
His dot moved downtown.
Then stopped.
I recognized the street immediately.
The Bellweather Hotel.
My chest tightened.
There it was.
Confirmation.
But then something strange happened.
Ten minutes later, the dot moved again.
Away from the hotel.
Across downtown.
Then it stopped at a restaurant.
Maybe they were eating first.
I took screenshots.
I wasn’t going there.
I didn’t need a dramatic confrontation.
I put the phone down.
At 8:03, it rang.
Lauren.
I stared at her name.
Why would she call me while she was supposedly with my husband?
I answered.
“Hey.”
Her voice sounded normal.
Too normal.
“Hey! Are you busy?”
“Not really.”
“I’m bored out of my mind.”
I frowned.
“Thought you were watching Netflix.”
“I am. Bad movie.”
I could hear television in the background.
Then a dog barked.
Lauren had a dog.
“Want to come over?” she asked.
I froze.
“What?”
“Come over. I have wine.”
My brain struggled to rearrange the facts.
Ryan was downtown.
Lauren was apparently home.
So who was Ryan meeting?
I needed to know.
“Maybe another night,” I said.
“You sure?”
“Yeah. I’m tired.”
We talked for another minute.
After we hung up, I sat completely still.
I had been so certain.
Lauren.
The message.
The hotel charge.
Her strange behavior.
But if Lauren was genuinely home…
Then whose message had I seen?
I replayed it in my mind.
She still doesn’t know about us.
Lauren.
Then I realized something.
I had seen the name quickly.
Only for a second.
I remembered “Lauren.”
But maybe I hadn’t seen Lauren Hayes.
Maybe I had seen another Lauren.
I opened social media.
Ryan’s friends.
Coworkers.
People we both knew.
Lauren Hayes.
Lauren Mitchell.
Lauren Bennett.
Lauren Carter.
My heart stopped at the fourth name.
Lauren Carter.
No.
“No,” I whispered.
Lauren Carter wasn’t my friend.
She was worse.
She was my younger sister.
I stared at her profile picture.
Ryan was standing beside her in it.
Not alone.
It was a family photo from Christmas.
Me.
Ryan.
Our children.
My parents.
And Lauren.
My sister.
Suddenly, I remembered the message exactly.
Not Lauren Hayes.
Just Lauren.
My mind had filled in the rest because that was the Lauren I had been suspicious of.
My hands started shaking again.
I called Rachel.
“Lauren isn’t with him.”
“What?”
“Wrong Lauren.”
“What do you mean wrong Lauren?”
“I think it’s my sister.”
Rachel went silent.
Then:
“Emily, don’t jump to that.”
“I’m not.”
I opened Ryan’s location again.
The restaurant where his dot had stopped was familiar.
I had been there once.
With my sister.
It was one of Lauren Carter’s favorite places.
Still, that proved nothing.
“Call her,” Rachel said.
I did.
Straight to voicemail.
Again.
Voicemail.
I texted.
Hey. What are you doing tonight?
No answer.
Ten minutes.
Twenty.
Then finally:
Sorry! At dinner with friends.
I stared at those words.
Friends.
“Ask where,” Rachel said.
I typed:
Anywhere good?
Three dots appeared.
Then disappeared.
Then appeared again.
Finally:
Just a little place near my apartment.
Lie.
The restaurant Ryan was at was nearly thirty minutes from her apartment.
I felt sick.
But I still needed proof.
Then the universe handed it to me.
My sister posted a photo to her social media story.
A cocktail.
Nothing else.
Just a glass sitting on a table.
Maybe she had forgotten I could see it.
Maybe she thought I wouldn’t notice.
But in the polished silver cocktail shaker beside the glass, there was a reflection.
A man.
Blue shirt.
Ryan’s blue shirt.
I took a screenshot.
Rachel whispered, “Oh my God.”
I couldn’t speak.
My husband.
My sister.
The two people who had spent years telling me they loved me.
Together.
I wanted to drive there.
I wanted to walk into that restaurant and put the phone between them.
I wanted to watch their faces.
Instead, I stayed home.
Because rage wanted confrontation.
But clarity wanted patience.
And I was beginning to understand something.
Ryan hadn’t proposed an open marriage because he wanted permission to start dating.
He had proposed it because he and Lauren needed a way to rewrite what they had already done.
If I agreed, eventually they could claim their relationship began afterward.
No affair.
No betrayal.
Just two consenting adults following rules.
Clever.
Almost.
Except they had made one mistake.
They had underestimated the woman doing their laundry.
I spent the next hour documenting everything.
Screenshots.
Credit card charges.
Dates.
Messages.
Anything I could legally access from our shared accounts.
Then I created a new email address and sent copies to myself.
At 10:38, Ryan’s location started moving.
At 11:06, the garage door opened.
I was sitting on the couch.
He walked inside looking almost cheerful.
“Hey.”
“Have fun?”
“Yeah.”
“Who’d you meet?”
His expression barely changed.
“A woman.”
I smiled.
“Anyone I know?”
There.
The smallest hesitation.
“No.”
I nodded.
“Okay.”
He stared at me.
“That’s it?”
“What else do you want?”
“I don’t know.”
“Good night, Ryan.”
I stood.
Then he said:
“Actually, Emily.”
I turned.
“Yeah?”
“I’ve been thinking.”
That sentence again.
Apparently nothing good in my marriage ever came after Ryan had been thinking.
“Maybe we need another rule.”
I almost smiled.
“What rule?”
“No dating people we already know.”
I stared at him.
The sheer nerve of it.
He had just come home from dinner with my sister.
And now he wanted to prevent me from dating anyone familiar.
“Interesting,” I said.
“I think it’ll prevent complications.”
“Sounds reasonable.”
He relaxed.
“Really?”
“Sure.”
I walked upstairs.
But I didn’t sleep.
The next morning, I met Daniel for coffee.
Not as revenge.
Not as a date.
For work.
He brought sketches for a small restaurant renovation his firm was handling.
For the next hour, we discussed lighting, floor plans, materials, and space.
At first, I was rusty.
Then something clicked.
I started seeing possibilities.
Daniel noticed.
“You really did this professionally?”
“For eight years.”
“Why did you stop?”
“Kids.”
“You were good.”
“Were?”
He smiled.
“Are.”
One word.
Are.
It shouldn’t have mattered.
But it did.
Because Ryan spoke about my old career like it belonged to someone who no longer existed.
Daniel spoke as though she were sitting across from him.
When we finished, he pushed the folder toward me.
“If you’re interested, the project is yours.”
I stared at him.
“You’re serious?”
“Completely.”
“I haven’t worked professionally in almost seven years.”
“Your ideas worked five minutes after you saw the plans.”
I looked at the folder.
For the first time in days, something other than betrayal filled my chest.
Excitement.
“I’ll do it.”
Daniel smiled.
“Good.”
When I returned home, Ryan was in the kitchen.
And Lauren—my sister—was sitting beside him.
She turned toward me with a bright smile.
“Surprise!”
I stopped in the doorway.
Every muscle in my body went rigid.
Ryan looked nervous.
Lauren looked cheerful.
Too cheerful.
“What are you doing here?” I asked.
She laughed.
“Wow. Nice to see you too.”
She stood and hugged me.
I let her.
And while her arms were around me, I smelled it.
Ryan’s cologne.
Faint.
But unmistakable.
When she pulled away, I smiled.
“Sorry. Long morning.”
Ryan noticed the folder in my hand.
“What’s that?”
“Work.”
His face changed.
“What work?”
“I picked up a freelance design project.”
Lauren blinked.
“You’re working again?”
“Looks like it.”
Ryan stared at me.
“With that guy?”
“Daniel?”
Lauren’s eyes immediately moved to Ryan.
Interesting.
“Yes,” I said. “With Daniel.”
Ryan’s jaw tightened.
“I thought we agreed not to date people we know.”
“I’m not dating him.”
“Yet,” Lauren said lightly.
The room went silent.
She smiled.
“Sorry. Joke.”
I looked at my sister.
Then at my husband.
And suddenly I understood something else.
Lauren knew about Daniel.
But I had never told her.
Rachel knew.
Ryan knew.
Nobody else.
So how did Lauren?
I set the folder on the counter.
“Actually,” I said, “I’m glad you’re both here.”
Ryan stiffened.
Lauren’s smile weakened.
“Why?”
“Because I was thinking we should have dinner together tonight.”
“All of us?” Lauren asked.
“Yes.”
“Why?”
I smiled.
“Family.”
Ryan looked at Lauren.
Lauren looked at Ryan.
Only for a fraction of a second.
But I saw it.
Fear.
“Sure,” Ryan said.
“Great.”
I walked upstairs.
Behind me, they began whispering.
I didn’t turn around.
Because dinner wasn’t going to be a confrontation.
Not yet.
I still needed to know exactly how long they had been lying.
At 6:30 that evening, the four of us sat around the table.
Lauren.
Ryan.
Me.
And Rachel.
Ryan hadn’t expected Rachel.
Neither had Lauren.
Rachel knew exactly why she was there.
We ate.
We talked.
We pretended.
Then halfway through dinner, I casually asked:
“Lauren, remember that weekend in May when you went to Nashville?”
Her fork stopped.
“Yeah.”
“Who did you go with?”
“Some friends.”
Ryan reached for his water.
“Which friends?”
Lauren laughed.
“Why are you interrogating me?”
“I’m not. I was thinking about taking Sophie there someday.”
“Oh.”
She named two women.
I knew both.
I smiled.
“Sounds fun.”
Under the table, Rachel’s foot touched mine.
Because earlier that afternoon, she had found something.
One of the women Lauren had named had posted photos from that exact weekend.
She had been in Boston.
The other had been attending her cousin’s wedding in Arizona.
Lauren had just lied.
And Ryan knew it.
After dinner, Lauren left quickly.
Rachel followed twenty minutes later.
Ryan helped me load the dishwasher.
For once.
Then his phone buzzed on the counter.
He grabbed it immediately.
But not before I saw the name.
Lauren.
My sister.
No doubt this time.
Ryan walked toward the hallway.
“I need to take this.”
I nodded.
“Sure.”
He disappeared into his office.
I waited.
Then my phone buzzed.
Rachel.
I FOUND SOMETHING.
My heart accelerated.
I typed:
What?
Her response came as a screenshot.
It was an old photograph from a Nashville restaurant’s public social media page.
Taken during that May weekend.
The restaurant had photographed customers during a live music event.
In the background of one picture sat two people.
Ryan.
And Lauren.
My husband had his hand resting on my sister’s knee.
I stared at the image.
Then another message from Rachel arrived.
Emily, look at the date.
I did.
And suddenly everything changed again.
Because that photograph wasn’t taken four months ago.
It wasn’t six months ago.
It had been taken almost eleven months earlier.
Before Ryan ever mentioned opening our marriage.
Before Melissa.
Before the hotel charges I had found.
Almost a full year of lies.
I saved the photograph.
Then I heard Ryan’s office door open.
He walked into the kitchen.
His face looked pale.
“Everything okay?” I asked.
“Yeah.”
He slipped his phone into his pocket.
Then he looked at me.
“Emily, we need to talk.”
I held his gaze.
“About what?”
He swallowed.
“Lauren.”
For one insane second, I thought he was finally going to confess.
Instead, he said:
“I think your sister might be having an affair with a married man.”
I stared at him.
The lie was so enormous that I almost admired his courage.
“Really?”
He nodded solemnly.
“She told me tonight.”
I slowly put down the glass I was holding.
“Did she tell you who?”
“No.”
“Interesting.”
“I think she’s scared.”
“I imagine she is.”
Ryan stepped closer.
“She asked me not to tell you.”
“But you’re telling me anyway.”
“You’re her sister.”
I smiled.
“You’re right.”
He relaxed slightly.
Then I asked:
“Ryan?”
“Yeah?”
“How long have you known?”
His eyes flickered.
“She told me tonight.”
“No.”
I kept smiling.
“How long have you known she’s having an affair?”
Ryan stared at me.
For the first time, real fear appeared in his face.
“Why are you asking me like that?”
“Like what?”
“Like you already know something.”
I stepped closer.
His phone buzzed again.
Lauren.
He ignored it.
I looked directly into his eyes.
And I realized I didn’t need to expose them tonight.
I could do something far more useful first.
I could let them keep lying.
Because every lie gave me another piece of the truth.
So I smiled.
“You’re right. I’m tired.”
Ryan searched my face.
Then he nodded.
“Let’s talk tomorrow.”
“Absolutely.”
He went upstairs.
I stayed in the kitchen.
A minute later, my phone buzzed again.
But this time it wasn’t Rachel.
It was Daniel.
Great news. The client loved your initial ideas. Call me tomorrow when you have time.
I looked at the message.
Then at the photograph of Ryan and Lauren.
Two doors were opening in front of me.
One led deeper into the life I had spent years trying to preserve.
The other led toward a version of myself I had almost forgotten.
For the first time, I knew which direction I wanted to move.
But before I could put my phone away, another message appeared.
Unknown number.
I opened it.
There was no greeting.
No explanation.
Only a photograph.
Ryan and Lauren standing outside a hotel.
Kissing.
The timestamp was from eight months earlier.
Underneath the picture were nine words:
You don’t know the worst part yet. Ask about the baby.
I read it twice.
Then a third time.
The kitchen seemed to disappear around me.
The baby?
My hands went cold.
Lauren didn’t have a baby.
At least…
Not one I knew about.
I immediately typed:
Who is this?
No response.
I called the number.
Straight to voicemail.
I tried again.
Nothing.
Then footsteps creaked upstairs.
Ryan.
I locked my phone and stared toward the staircase.
For the first time since our anniversary dinner, I wasn’t calm anymore.
Because an affair could destroy a marriage.
An affair with my sister could destroy a family.
But a baby?
A baby meant there was something much bigger hiding beneath everything I had discovered.
And suddenly I understood why Ryan had been so desperate to change the rules of our marriage before the truth came out.
He wasn’t trying to get permission to have an affair.
He was trying to create an excuse for something that could no longer stay hidden.
And whatever that secret was…
My sister knew it.
Ryan knew it.
And apparently, a stranger knew it too.
I looked at the photograph one final time.
Then I whispered into the empty kitchen:
“What did you two do?”
END OF PART 3
One Comment on “PART 3: On Our 10th Anniversary, My Husband Suggested We Start Seeing Other People — I Agreed, and His Smile Didn’t Last Long”